Talk:The Cutie Mark Chronicles/@comment-3498154-20110420132447/@comment-71.203.94.83-20111028224336

There is NO way Pinkie could ever have been that sad filly on the rock farm. Sure, she was depressed in Party of One, but that was from the trauma of believing that her friends had left her. Also, the tale was far-fetched and Pinkie Pie is an unreliable narrator. Do the math. And it's true that she looks nothing remotely like the other rock farmers. I'm sure Pinkie thinks that it happened, but she thinks in slightly different way than you and me.