Talk:Trixie/@comment-5065943-20121114024738/@comment-99.13.33.41-20121123032016

Why would Trixie be banished to the moon?

Celestia was FORCED to do that to Luna because there was no other option. She couldn't fight Nightmare Moon for reasons such as "she's my sister" and the fact that's she powerful enough to subdue Celestia and set in motion ever lasting night. You can say Celestia intentionally didn't fight Nightmare Moon so Twilight and her friends could take care of the mess, but this much is certain: Celestia had to hand over the fate of Equestria to 1,000 years delay and six ponies who don't posess incredibly magical powers and the ability to banish ponies to the moon and turn things into stone. For some reason, she just couldn't defeat Nightmare Moon on her own.

All that put aside, you really think Celestia would be willing to send a pony that is helpless against Celestia to the moon? You think that's realistic? No matter what Trixie has done, it doesn't compare to Nightmare Moon. Trixie probably wouldn't survive on the moon considering the only connection she has to it is her cutie mark. Celestia probably wouldn't be up to a death sentence.?

Also, considering how many times we've seen several of the same background ponies in the same scene, I think they just reused the Trixie model for several scenes and not for plot purposes.

Summery: Celestia banishing a pony to the moon is neither cool, nor funny, nor realistic. It's absolute and total isolation and torture.