Talk:Honest Apple/@comment-4899875-20170607220039/@comment-4899875-20170607223823

It was her event, but she wasn't a judge. She specifically told Pinkie Pie and Spike that AJ was going to be the 3rd judge. It was never said that she was going to be a judge. So saying that AJ, Hoity Toity, and Photo Finish were going to be judges and fixating on them so much and having them and not Rarity judging the entire time before that made it seem a bit out of nowhere when Rarity cast a vote and like there would only be 3 judges.

Not only that, but when Rarity said that AJ was going to be the 3rd judge, that would've made Rarity the 4th judge, but Rarity didn't even have 4 judges, so how can Rarity be the 4th judge before they even have 4 judges? That would be like me saying "I'm going to get my 4th tattoo" when I've only had 2 tattoos. That's so weird.

If Rarity was always planning on being a judge, then she would be the 1st judge, Hoity Toity and Photo Finish would've been the 2nd and 3rd judges, and AJ would've been the 4th judge because it's impossible for her to be the 3rd judge because they already had 3 judges and she would've been the 4th to become a judge.