Talk:My Little Pony Best Gift Ever/@comment-3410511-20181215183839/@comment-915779-20190418150745

Chronologically this takes place after S05E19 and before S05E25, regardless of what the staff says ... because: - Starlight Glimmer is missing and not considered existing - Spike transformation in season 8 is missing - Flurry heart exists So the one in Manehattan didn't exist until S06E03, but the one in Canterlot does, which was opened in S05E14. And it's silly how the writer of the special is the writer of the episode that Caterlot Boutique opened in. But maybe the outline of the special was made before season 5? That's the only sane reason I can think of, other than the writers really not taking consistency into account.