Talk:Twilight's Kingdom - Part 2/@comment-26973802-20140507231258

Really? They spoiled the ending already? If this is legit... I'll have to say reimprisoning Tirek in Tartarus was a weak move on Meghan's part for four reasons.

1.) He escaped Tartarus once so who's to say he won't do it again? At least with Discord you assume Celestia takes measures to prevent him escaping again before you find out she wants him reformed

2.) Celestia and Luna imprisoned him with their own magic. Why didn't they do that again from the beginning? Maybe the same reasons they didn't banish Sombra again - they knew he'd keep coming back unless he is defeated another way.

3.) If Celestia and Luna can imprison him with their own magic, and Rainbow Power does the same, that means Rainbow Power is only as powerful as Celestia and Luna's magic. Which would make all the hard work going into Rainbow Power seem pointless, even turning him to stone a la Discord would be better.

4.) Meghan killed Chrysalis, Sombra, and the Plunderseeds. Katie Cook only retconned Chrysalis's death if you take the comics as canon. Tirek looks to be more dark, malevolent, and menacing than the three of them put together, and his battles just as epic. If any villain should be destroyed in a spectacular technicolor rainbowfied way it should be Tirek. Otherwise it's a big letdown after everything before.

Also it gives no mention to Celestia, Luna, and Cadance after the transfer so did they die or something? Same with Discord, what happens to him when Tirek takes his energy? Not that I'd be too torn up about his death after he goes evil again and disregards his friendship with Fluttershy just as I feared he would. Not to mention Twilight's princess insecurities: She's supposed to be over that, and only triggered once Celestia sends Discord after Tirek. Not before!

Then again I did read a similar summary on a site that conflicts with this one and has to be false even if this one isn't true: It said Tirek used the Rainbow of Darkness to turn ponies into monsters (like G1), and Discord betrays the ponies for Tirek but seeing the power of Twilight's friendship melts his heart and fully reforms him, and he gives Twilight her key - the journal - and when they defeat Tirek it turns the Everfree Forest into a peaceful forest and turns the old castle into Twilight's castle. But given what we know even without Rock Father's summary, that has to be fake, even though he claimed he was told this by his uncle at DHX.