Talk:A Hearth's Warming Tail/@comment-23896133-20160519224707

For me I'd probably rate this a 6.5 / 10. I loved all the songs and I liked the casting of the characters in the story. Unfortunately what holds it back for me is that it's an adaptation of A Christmas Carol. Not that doing an adaptation of the tale is bad, but I've seen it done so many times that after awhile I just get bored with it.

It does do some things to change the story up, like Snowfall Frost trying to erase Hearth's Warming history, and I liked too how this wasn't the whole episode, I like how it was just a story, and the moments where the story were being interrupted were funny, but by the end of the day it doesn't change the same plot line of a Scrooge being dragged around with 3 ghosts to learn the true meaning of Christmas.

It's not a bad episode honestly, on the contrary I'd say this was a relatively harmless episode, and I would actually re watch this during Christmas, but it's not my favorite Season Six episodes. I'd say it's one of the better episodes of the new season.

Also I won't give names but if you're somebody who loves this episode, please don't try to force the person to change their perspective or claim their opinions are "horrid" just because they disagree with what you said, if he / she didn't like it, it's their opinion, they have the right to say they didn't like it just as much as you have the right to share why you liked it.