Talk:Derpy/@comment-67.183.212.103-20130311031225/@comment-5041273-20130319002743

Well Derpy's definitely older than Twilight Sparkle, because in the Cutie Mark Chronicles when Twilight's having her flashback, it shows Twilight as a filly, and in the background, it has Derpy looking like she does in the present. I could see Derpy as Dinky's mother, but Amethyst Star looks nothing like Derpy, and she is older than Twilight as well.