Talk:Applejack/@comment-68.32.216.42-20130523033718/@comment-4706498-20130616033324

I'm sorry I'm interrupting a perfectly good argument here (I personally agree that they're supposed to be dead but we're not going to get any proof beside the star shout-out because it's a kids show, so believe what you want), but I had to nail OP's earlier point:

' "They haven't been seen." True, but neither has Dash's nor Fluttershy's parents appeared. You don't say they are dead, so why are only AJ's considered dead? '

Excuse me, anon, but haven't you heard that Dashie is an orphan? At least until Games Ponies Play, I've heard that was the most common theory. Heck, we've seen Pinkie's parents, but there's an AU parody that says she's an orphan. You really can't dissuade the fandom.