Talk:Sounds of Silence/@comment-30566729-20181015015150/@comment-7345250-20181211131059

Excuse me, but a lot of creative liberties went into the Sirens.

More to the point, you're putting words in Imperfect's mouth.

He clearly stated only that Chinese mythology cannot be extrapolated to MLP. It's not a question of what is being said on-screen. It is a question of people lifting lore from a completely different medium and projecting it onto creatures in a fictional world.

One could also claim the windigos are cannibals, the pukwudgies can throw fire, and that the hydra can regrow severed heads. Is it possible? Yes. Is it actually substantiated? Absolutely not. All it takes is one glance at the hippogriffs to see that MLP has its own unique lore for each creature.