Talk:Feeling Pinkie Keen/@comment-71.227.7.35-20110622044530/@comment-75.155.68.181-20110807022654

YES to this. i was annoyed that she seemed to be put into a role of the "scientist" because she definitely did not act like it. makes me question the writers knowledge of how science works.

i just don't see it fair to justify what they did how they did. it's sad to see this small blemish on what is an honestly amazing show. i almost wish they could make a new episode re-assessing the situation, showing that twilight was doing "bad science", and show how a true scientist would react to the situation. considering the vast amount of observational evidence in support of repeatable events (at least in this one episode), there definitely should have been further study put into it. just accepting the lack of knowledge with out even giving it a true scientific shot is painful. twilight would have been better setting up some events too. say, box pinkie pie off, test results of making things fall while completely out of her range of perception. etc. etc.

just a sad addition to a great show. makes me sad because i want to show people derpy hooves, but not the awful philosophy.