Talk:Pinkie Apple Pie/@comment-11634302-20160104153708/@comment-26855152-20160104160415

We currently don't know for sure. But we do know that Pinkie definitely was not being sarcastic because she read on a geneology record about them being distantly related. However, the scroll was smudged, so no one could find the truth. Despite this, the Apples still consider Pinkie a part of their family after all they went through together. And after Hearthbreakers, the Pies feel the same way. Hope this helps.