Talk:Granny Smith/@comment-68.37.153.40-20120718043217

In the first episode, Princess Celestia gathers the most powerful elements known to Ponyville. These became known as the Elements of Harmony. Princess Celestia uses these elements to defeat her younger sister Luna, who at the time refused to lower the moon. That was over 1000 years ago.

Now fast foward to Season 2, Episode 11 where Granny Smith tells the story of how she discovered Zapp apples in the Everfree Forest and founded Ponyville and made a business deal by making Zapp apple jam. The pony she makes the business deal with is none other than Diamond Tiara's father, Filthy Rich.

So not only do we find out that Ponyville is 1000+ years old and Princess Celestia assembled the Elements of Harmony there, but also that Granny Smith founded Ponyville and that Filthy Rich was around at that time too.

Are both Granny Smith and Filthy Rich over 1000 years old, or is it just an error/ bad storyline writing.

~J.A.S.61598@3:00pm