Talk:Sunset Shimmer/@comment-24101825-20140708211557/@comment-26973802-20140712233557

1: First, she's so evil and sinister and creepy, and with villains like her I'm not satisfied any other way. (as opposed to villains like Discord who are fun to have around) Second, although she's my favorite villain, her turning Twilight's friends, brother, and mentor against her of their own accord was the most depressing moment of the show and I want her dead for that.

2: Why would they have even made a comic about her? Because Katie Cook is a pegasister who, like many, believed Chrysalis survived, and she brought her back knowing many would buy the comics instantly if their favorite villain was in it.

If she was dead, Hasbro would've vetoed the comic or declared it non-canon. Although Hasbro apparently sets some standards, they don't care if the comics are canon or not, they just said "You can use the characters". Look at how Heather's comics depicted Nightmare Moon transformations/possessions, yet that was contradicted in Princess Twilight Sparkle.

And if you're so sure that she's dead, why don't you sent a tweet to Meghan McCarthy about it? Because I know someone who hangs out with her at conventions and she's never mentioned Chrysalis to him once, not even when he sent her a tweet asking whether Chrysalis would return. I think the reason she's completely silent about Chrysalis is so we can make up our own minds about her.