Talk:Pinkie Apple Pie/@comment-32136229-20140112181432/@comment-11491781-20140113144329

What if Slenderpony is the father of -both- Pinkie Pie and Aunt Applesauce?

Slenderpony is immortal, propably older than Discord and Celestia, and could have any number of daughters he wants. He got Cloudy Quartz pregnant in 978 P.L.* but he actually existed, and looked exactly the same back in... 880 P.L., when he got an Apple Family member pregnant, and thus Aunt Applesauce was conceived.


 * Post Luna s' banishment