Talk:Shadow Play - Part 2/@comment-24095984-20171024174808

Error: Timeline Paradox

So Celestia and Luna defeated Tirek and Discord before Luna became Nightmare Moon. Which means that it happens more than 1000 years ago. Starswirl was shocked that Celestia and Luna were bigger 1000 years later. BUT, in flashback to Nightmare Moon and Discord's defeat, Celestia and Luna were at the same size as they are right now.

To pull it up a little bit further, it's been let's say 3 years since Season 1 Episode 1 which marks exactly 1000 years of Luna's banishment. Given the time, today must've been 1003 (at least) years.

The Pillars of Old Equestria were put at a limbo exactly 1000 years before the Season 7 Episode 25 (if proven precise). Which puts Nightmare Moon banishment BEFORE The Pillars went to Limbo. Why Starswirl didn't comment on this is weird.

It's also shocking to know that at the point when they defeat Tirek and Discord: They still takes Homework from Starswirl!

Extra Question in case that question is solved, WHERE IS CELESTIA AND LUNA? A great enemy that threatens entire world is on the loose, and they remain in Canterlot? The combined magic of 3 or even 4 pony princesses (aka Gods) would be really helpful! Don't tell me Twillight can't send them letters about current crisis (coz Spike). Cadence, I could understand that Crystal Empire is very far and there is little window of time to wait for her.

Bonus points if anyone can give logical answers without mentioning Continuity Error, Animation Error, and Storyboard Error.