Talk:Pinkie Pie/@comment-24909678-20191016022122/@comment-25563752-20191018053647

Yeah, that's totally a girl. Maybe she was intended to be a boy, or Miller wanted her to be a boy, but she was clearly made to be a girl. Whatever the case, even if you are the writer/maker/etc, you can't claim one thing when it's very clearly not true. Li'l Cheese is very obviously a girl. She has the long eyelashes that only fillies have, and the body type too, as there is a cear difference between the two. So, yeah, maybe making her a boy was the intention, but wasn't what they ended up giving us. It might even have been a mistake. Ccreative teams do make mistakes sometimes. Maybe there was miscommuniction or something.

Despite what writers claim, not everything they say is accurate or true, especially when what takes place is directly contradictary to what takes place. For example, think about what JK Rowling said about Hermione. Afer the Cursed Child came out, where Hermione was played by a black woman, she said that Hermione "could be black" because it was never specifically stated. Despite this, there are several lines and descriptions throughout the book series that make it very clear that Hermione is not black, despite what Rowling said. I view this as the same thing. No matter what Miller says, Li'l Cheese is very clearly a girl, and as far as I'm concerned, she is.