Talk:Generosity (song)/@comment-5595999-20140104215348/@comment-3146930-20140119150824

I disagree, as I still think Art of the Dress is the best Rarity song and does a better job of displaying her generous nature and who she is. In Art of the Dress, she is willing to make dresses for all her friends (for free) and changes her original ideas in order to give them what (they think) they want. Even when it becomes apparent that her friends are wearing her down, she never once stops and keeps trucking along to give her friends what they want.

In this song however, it does show that Rarity is generous, but it feels more like it is shoving that message in front of your face the entire time. Not to mention it is kind of weird that despite talking about how generous she is, Spike is still forced to carry all the bags. Rarity has magical powers and could probably help with a few or toss some more rubies around to get someone to help; but she gives him a hotdog instead (which he never even got a chance to eat).

Still a good song, but I don't think it is the best at showing who she is; mostly because this song is tossing the message in your face while Art of the Dress shows us without directly telling us.