Talk:Pinkie Pie/@comment-32136229-20130223121242

Season 1 Pinkie > Season 2 Pinkie = Season 3 Pinkie

Season 1 Pinkie was pretty much the perfect Pinkie for me. Most of her jokes hit right, her randomness was not overblown and her characterization in the overall season was done right.

Season 2 Pinkie was pretty much a mixed bag for me in terms of both her characterization and her humor. While there are definitely episodes that made use of her well like Season 1, there were also episodes that just didn't handle her quite too well. I can get some laughs out of some of her jokes, but at times, there were some other jokes that just didn't hit too well. Not to mention she was characterized as a bit over-the-top in some episodes for the sake of humor. The Last Roundup is the best example of this. It seems that in this season, she has devolved from a pony who acts very random but still pretty balanced to "LOL RANDOM" pony. At least some of her episodes such as Baby Cakes and A Friend in Deed portrayed her well and brought up some mature developments to her character.

Season 3 Pinkie didn't really change her all that much, though she seemed to be a bit more balanced compared to Season 2. While not as over-the-top as she was in some episodes of Season 2, some of her jokes still didn't hit very well, but I guess they did handle her a bit better than in the second season in terms of characterization. So for me, this season's Pinkie was pretty much a mixed bag when it comes to humor, but in terms of characterization, she was alright.