Talk:Secrets and Pies/@comment-31873439-20170723175837/@comment-26423071-20170728230839

Not really.

To be honest...I'm not really a fan of Pinkamena. It seems an unnecesarily mean-spirited thing for a lighthearted and hopeful show.

And it doesn't make any narrative sense. To counter what I say below, the rest of the Pie family keep their nastiness outwards. They don't hide their feelings or emotions from anyone. So Pinkie having this "Mister Hyde"/"Gollum" side to her doesn't really fit.