Talk:The Perfect Pear/@comment-26113747-20170806200256

Alright, there's already enough debate on whether or not AJ's parents are dead or not, so how about this question.... Obviously Pear Butter gave birth to Big Macintosh, Applejack, and finally Apple Bloom. From the episode Cutie Mark Chronicles, we assume that Apple Bloom has not yet been born, and that Big Mac and AJ are living on the farm with Granny Smith, until AJ goes to Manehattan to live with her Aunt and Uncle Orange. We can reasonably assume that the Oranges might have a little info on what happened to Pear Butter and Bright Macintosh, seeing as how they are related.

My point is, Pear Butter gave birth to 3 foals. So where did her and Bright go after she gave birth? Apple Bloom was the last one to be born, so how did she come into the care of Granny Smith? Did they drop her off in a basket and then disappear? Did they give it to Granny and make her promise not to tell AJ and Big Mac so as not to stir up bad memories? Most importantly, why were they not a part of their kids' lives? Why did Pear Butter and Bright Macintosh go away each time after having a foal? The questions go on and on.