Talk:Limestone Pie and Marble Pie/@comment-26031013-20160306083810/@comment-27739895-20160306095457

I see what you're getting at. Honestly, I believe the production staff did not expect MLP to grow so big and did not plan Marble Pie to return as a more developed character. That might explain the lack of foreshadowing about Marble Pie's change.

Nevertheless, I think this change can still make sense. Children can go through pretty dramatic changes in their teenage years. How many parents have been shocked to see their child unexpectedly become an emo, a goth, a metalhead or even change gender? Given her family setting (very stern and traditionalist parents who may be hard to talk to, an overwhelmingly aggressive sister, an overwhelmingly exuberant one, and Maud who isn't easy to approach either) I wouldn't be surprised that a slightly introverted child might have become as shy as Marble Pie is. So yes, I personally have no doubts that the filly and the mare are the same pony.

Regarding your missing comments, have you checked back to see if they truly are missing? The main Wikia servers occasionally have network issues (happened just a few days ago), which are totally unrelated to the MLP Wikia staff. Comment/blog updates consequently get very messed up sometimes. I had a long comment of mine disappear on this very page too but, eventually, it's right there down bellow (and it's an indirect reply to another one of your messages, as a matter of fact).