Talk:The Hearth's Warming Club/@comment-30566729-20190307170241/@comment-4531340-20190308095712

I think it may have been a bluff on Twilight's part - she knew she couldn't keep them, and she also knew that they didn't. At least, that's one way to look at it. And as they mention in the episode, it's more meaningful when the guilty party confesses of their own volition, rather than under coercion.

And being brash and in-your-face is just Rainbow Dash's style.