Talk:The Failure Song/@comment-1405611-20120717222605

Do we really need all the singing Spike references? Shouldn't those be under his page, perhaps under a new header titled "Songs" (or even "Past Songs")?

Perhaps this would be a better way to word it, keeping it simple (cleaning up the wordiness, too):

This is the first time Spike has sung in the G4 series.

There, simple, to the point. If we must have references to his other songs, here (I still argue they should be under a dedicated section on his own page), then I propose:

''This is the first time Spike has sung in the G4 series. Previously, he sang in "I'll Go It Alone," a duet with Baby Lickety-Split in the 1986 G1 movie "My Little Pony: The Movie" (voiced by Charlie Adler)[1] and "Someone To Look Up To," a duet with a baby eaglet named Weston in the 1987 G1 episode "Spike's Search" from 'My Little Pony 'n Friends, Series 2 (also voiced by Adler)[2]'''. The G3 redesigned Spike (voiced by Brian Drummond) also sang at the end of the 2006 direct-to-video movie "My Little Pony: The Princess Promenade."[3]''

[1] –http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RUKJh77bCrI (video clip, "I'll Go It Alone," 2012-07-17)

[2] –http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hqmaiAWa_Jw (video clip, "Someone To Look Up To," 2012-07-17)

[3] –http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cNK25T51ExY (video clip, song title unkown, 2012-07-17)

That's my version of it. Consensus, anybody? Does this look good? Feel free to add to it or modify and copy-paste. I think either version would be better than the mess up there, now. Of course, I prefer the keep-it-simple approach. If we must include all of Spike's singing roles, then we might as well document them correctly!

Sevenscence ( talk | blog | contribs )