Talk:Pinkie Pie/@comment-5532318-20130202074655/@comment-32136229-20130202151534

Eh, I thought Season 1 Pinkie is the best Pinkie, because she doesn't have as much OOC moments as she did in Season 2 and Season 3 (though in Season 3, she doesn't have as much OOC moments as she did in Season 2). However, I can't deny that she definitely had some great character development in Season 2 with episodes such as Baby Cakes and A Friend in Deed, which is why I still feel that she was still good in that season. However, those character developments does not excuse her characterization in some of her supporting roles in episodes such as The Mysterious Mare Do Well, The Last Roundup, Read It and Weep, Putting Your Hoof Down (though in a lesser extent) and MMMystery on the Friendship Express.

While Season 3 didn't really change too much on the characterization department for her (well, aside from Too Many Pinkie Pies, which managed to develop her character further), at least she had less bad characterizations than in Season 2. Even Wonderbolts Academy, the episode where I thought she was unusually over the top, still managed to give her some good characterization, with her feeling very concerned towards Rainbow Dash. This is why I thought that her quality of characterization in Season 3 slightly surpasses her quality of characterization in Season 2. However, I do have to say that when it comes to character development, Season 2 was definitely the best season for her.

So in my opinion: Season 1 Pinkie > Season 3 Pinkie > Season 2 Pinkie