Talk:Pinkie Pie/@comment-5926076-20130224201406/@comment-32136229-20130225074323

I'm not sure if AKR writing another Pinkie episode is a good idea. While I liked how she's written her in her Season 1 episodes and A Friend in Deed, I didn't like how she's written her in The Last Roundup and MMMystery on the Friendship Express, with the former characterizing her as being unusually over the top (plus, she wasn't really all that funny, aside from a few moments) and the latter characterizing her as being really dumb (seriously, she should have already been given the hint by Twilight that the cake was bitten).

Also, I actually find a few of her portrayals in Season 2 to be way worse than in Season 3. Even despite her character being exaggerated in Wonderbolts Academy, she at least show that she cares about her friends here (in this case, Rainbow Dash). While she did act pretty dumb in Games Ponies Play, she at least was doing it to distract the "inspector". While the season didn't really improved her portrayal all that much from Season 2, at least it didn't characterize Pinkie horribly, as some Season 2 episodes did.

I hope that in Season 4, that AKR doesn't write Pinkie as horribly as she did in TLR and MotFE and write her more like in Bridle Gossip, Fall Weather Friends, The Best Night Ever and A Friend in Deed.