Talk:Manehattan Mysteries/@comment-24864975-20140721143124/@comment-24864975-20140724002357

Well, when Trixie removed her hat the while she was onstage, there was nothing there. But when she removed it after discovering that the real one was missing, there it was! So although he wasn't around when the fake one went missing, he was right next to Applejack when the fake one was found under her hat, and he was right next to Trixie when the real one was discovered missing from the safe and found underneath her hat. That being said, if my logic is correct (and if the writers keep on track), he'd most likely be Rough Diamond accomplist.