Talk:Rarity/@comment-31556666-20120710204513/@comment-31556666-20120720102249

@MJNSEIFER

Pinkie was unintenionally a jerk in Luna Eclipsed because while it's fun to be scared, Pinkie approaches it the wrong way. Luna saves Pipsqueak from drowning and Pinkie says she's trying to eat his flesh. Luna's been gone for 1000 years, and is a hero. What's so bad? So in Pinkie's defense, she wasn't trying to be mean to Luna. But she says that she's trying to be fun but doesn't realise it's hurting Luna. Infact, I take back what I said. Pinkie is doing this unintenionally so I'll cut her some slack. The real episode I didn't like her in was A Friend in Deed. Her Smile Smile Smile song is great but she destroyes Cranky Dooodle's life, doesn't want to accept that he wants to be kept alone and doesn't even listen to Twilight or Rainbow Dash about it. I think I disliked her more in A Friend in Deed.

As for Twilight, you wouldn't really except her to throw a party. She acts excitable, shne acts partygoing the whole time. This isn't the Twilight I know. Her character in this episode is basically Pinkie Pie's character. And like I said in my review of Griffon the Brush Off, it shows that Twilight and Pinkie are alot different from eachother. So then what were they doing here? Why did they even put Twilight in the episode? Make Rarity and Applejack go to Sugarcube Corner, not Twilight's library. And I know that the restriction in Season 1 was to have Twilight appear in every episode. Okay then, make her already be in Sugarcube Corner with Pinkie when Applejack and Rarity come in. Either that or could've saved this episode for Season 2.