Talk:Derpy/@comment-172.6.30.82-20130304070609/@comment-5513888-20130308010728

With that logic, I must be related to the president, since noone said u wasn't.

Who's to say Derpy wasn't their for another team competing? Or maybe she just happened to be next to Dinky and Amethyst by coincidence. Sure, what you've presented may be because Derpy, Dinky, and Amithyst are related, but it cannot prove beyond reasonable doubt that Derpy is related to Amethyst and Dinky.

However, that's not to say that everyone who depicts them as such is wrong. I for one encourage the use of imagination, to mold the lives of these unknown characters and provide them a background to their life. However, there isn't any substantial evidence that proves this depiction is actually canon to the show.