Talk:Shadow Play - Part 2/@comment-7345250-20171014135646/@comment-7345250-20171024190830

No one is saying any of the other finales are perfect, but in my opinion this is the weakest so far by a significant margin.

And since the Pony of Shadows legend is Josh's own invention, it seems very lazy of him to introduce a completely different character under the same name with no real explanation. Not to mention, as Katmare called it, a sheer absence of fact-checking with regard to the everything else.