Talk:Applejack's "Day" Off/@comment-26423071-20160422201807

I have to take issue with the whole "Pinkie can't run the farm because Magical Mystery Cure" thing.

In that episode, she wasn't in her right mind. Her Cutie Mark got switched, which means her brain was scrambled to some degree (more than usual, I mean). For all we know, that wasn't even Pinkie, but "Pinkamena" (Pinkie's default personality that she tries hard to supress ever since she saw Rainbow Dash's Sonic Rainboom as a filly, the personality we saw during "Party of One").

In THIS episode, her mind would be clear, so she wouldn't mess up.

And AGAIN: one of the "things to do" in "Too Many Pinkies" was helping Applejack raise a barn. If Applejack trust Pinkie with helping her raise a barn, why wouldn't Applejack trust Pinkie with running Sweet Apple Acres?

And if pinkie is as big a screwup as you think she is, why did Applejack ask Pinkie to help her raise a barn?