Talk:The Last Roundup/@comment-85.221.114.198-20120122152407/@comment-213.184.195.130-20120123072636

@Flying High, MJNSEIFER & SailorKnightWing. Thats the point, I've never seen Derpy as retarded, I love her as the cross-eyed clumsy pony she is, thats why I really did not like the the way she was portrayed in this episode. First of all they called her Derpy, I have nothing against it as something we fans call her, but her name is directly based of the, actually really offensive, word "derp" witch is used to describe the sound people with speech impairment, so that they chose to use this as her canon name is just weird, why not Ditzy or something, it's not like they care about the fanon names *cogh*Heartstrings*cogh*. Her voice also indicates a slight speech problem. In addition to this, she was also stupid, not only clumsy, but stupid. And again, don't get me wrong, I love Derpy, thats why it saddens me that when she actually gets a role, it's this half-assed attempt of pleasing the fans. Well, it does seem like it worked and everyone except me liked it, so I guess its just me.

@SailorKnightWing & A Wikia contributor. Yeah, it´s true that she didn't lie, but I really can't see the honest part in holding back information. But I can see why they used that as en excuse, cause I can't really see this plot work with anyone other than AJ, she is the only athlete except RD, but since she's the element of loyalty, there is no way she would choose not to come back.