Talk:Magic Duel/@comment-3410511-20121128033653/@comment-5513888-20121130042101

Try to be more sophisticated in your arguement. I will never side with someone who thinks insulting another wikis member means he or she must be right.

Prince Doopliss is partially correct. While Twilight is not necessarily weak, she will not defeat Trixie, at least not alone. The fact she is defeated a first time proves that. She is going to need help.

However, in regards to Prince Doopliss' arguement that Twilight is weak, I have a few questions: to pony standards, is Twilight weak? She needs help to defeat the major villains, thats true. But whenever the ponies of Ponyville are faced with danger, all they do is panic. In the world of Equestria, I would not conclude Twilight is not weak (in other words, compared to other ponies, she isn't exactly weak. She isn't the strongest, but she isn't weak either.)

Second: if Twilight is given the amulet by Zecora, and it contributes to Trixie's defeat, how is it Zecora's victory? The stone alone is useless to her, she can't use magic. Put it like this: a man engages in a swordfight and loses his sword, then is given a sword by a friend. The friend knows nothing about dueling; the sword is a family heirloom. The first man then challenges his enemy to a rematch and slays his enemy, does the victory go to the friend? I say it doesnt.