Talk:Magical Mystery Cure/@comment-4876777-20130217024712/@comment-27.253.106.66-20130218031331

You do have a point with the reaction of Derpy fans being somewhat akin to a father after seeing the return of a prodigal son. I like that analogy and I think I can relate to that.

The episode whilst not perfect did somethings right for me as I mentioned in a previous reply. Sure, it definitely wasn't the greatest episode ever when we compare it to other season finales (The Best Night Ever and A Canterlot Wedding), this ranks easily the worst of the lot. But if we compare the episode to the show as WHOLE with people flinging words like 'forgetable', I can't help but raise a few eyebrows. People have their opinions about the episode as 'bad' or 'terrible'. That is fine, they are entitled to their opinion. But downright calling the episode forgetable is simply absurd. We are about a few days since the episode has officially aired and even in the week prior and this issue has generated so much controversy. I could imagine a few months down the line, people will still talk about this and these are one of the issues that could split the fanon continuity. Whether which side of the fence a fan sits on with regards to the whole Twilight Alicorn transformation issue, the episode is anything but forgetable.