Talk:Starlight Glimmer/@comment-11634302-20160524002801/@comment-1031724-20160526052242

There are differing opinions on her

Some think she is an underwhelming villain compared to your more menacing, almost demonic villains such as Chrysalis, Sombra, Tirek, the Dazzlings, even Nightmare Moon and Discord.

Some think she was a great villain in The Cutie Map, but a horrible childish villain in The Cutie Remark (even though she was more extreme in that one).

And some think that because of what she did in The Cutie Remark, she did not deserve to be forgiven and should have been sent to Tartarus - one way or the other.

Others are tired of the villain redemptions (and btw a certain other show is going for that, redeeming all of its surviving villains even though it killed two of them after), or else not wanting her to become one of the Mane 6, thus either "changing" the show from what it was, or else hogging the spotlight as the main character (and after Newbie Dash and The Saddle Row Review, those fears are unfounded. I was disappointed, but the needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few, or the one)