Talk:The Hearth's Warming Club/@comment-24206774-20180804192241

Good episode, but I do have one criticism (and please hear me out):

I think Twilight should have chosen a better punishment for the young six. I get the extra lessons as a punishment, but keeping all of the young six at the school for 2 whole weeks to learn those extra lessons?

Sure, she would have notified all the familes, perhaps inviting them to stay with the students at the school, but still...maybe it should have been to have the culprit (Gallus) be given detention after the holiday break was over and learn those extra lessons then. You can't keep someone from their familes even if they did something wrong, especially if they had been away from home for an entire semester. Besides, we all know that Twilight would have gotten on Novo's bad side again had Silverstream not been with the Hippogriffs for the three day celebration.

Personally, I felt that the punishment was a BIT too harsh because that would have been interfearing with personal matters.

Or...

Maybe have the culprit (Gallus) go home for the holiday and THEN come back to the school early for the extra freindship lessons. That would have been another route Twilight would have gone with.

...

Not a bad episode aside from that. Just offering a bit of criticism.