Talk:Pinkie Pride/@comment-10265857-20140201162322/@comment-10390252-20140201165426

Personally?

8.5/10

The writing and comic timing was spot-on. As a Pinkie Pie character episode, this was a tour-de-force. Also, for a throw-away one-episode supporting character, Cheese Sandwich was wonderfully written and very three-dimensional.

On the 'negatives' side, the songs were invariably a bit 'meh' to me. Only the chorus of 'Make a Wish' sticks in mind. Outside the main protagonist/antagonist duo, the characterisations were either paper-thin or actually painfully OOC, especially the rest of the M6's reaction to Cheese Sandwich (with the slight exception of Twilight Sparkle).

So: Far from a perfect episode but the positives vastly outweight the negatives.