Talk:Leap of Faith/@comment-32136229-20140328174402/@comment-10390252-20140328194312

My gut feeling is this:

1) The tonic is just snake oil - expensive and medicinally worthless;

2) AJ bought some tonic and told Granny (who was going through a bad patch) that it would help her. It did, possibly through the placebo effect;

3) The conversation we saw was AJ talking with the Flim-Flam's ringer who is now feeling morally vindicated that his lies may have helped at least one pony.

Poor AJ!