Talk:Granny Smith/@comment-66.229.131.23-20120307203454/@comment-49.144.236.110-20120415152649

@Xeoxer

I don't really think there's an inconsistency. Hearth's Warming Eve was more like the founding and division of Equestria within the three Pony tribes. The areas which they claimed after the division were more like regions rather than towns. From what I've read, Equestria's a country so it would be illogical for a country to have only 3 cities, and since there were other cities mentioned, like Fillydelphia or Manehattan, Ponyville is most likely to be one of the towns in the country. So the Apple family founded Ponyville, a town, but not the Earth Pony Region.