Talk:Dungeons & Discords/@comment-15889853-20160825182347/@comment-26855152-20160826090810

Humor is subjective. I personally thought those expressions were really funny because unlike Twilight, seeing Pinkie stressed is a rare treat. A lot of Pinkie's comedy came from the journey though. All that narration, the way she broke out of her "serious" (if you can even call it that) demeanor, and interaction with characters we have either previously seen or are a reference to something else. It was Pinkie being Pinkie, and I loved every second of it.

And I think her genuine desire to make others happy was shown here. I have a very different opinion of the party planning cave than you do, because I think it's a strong display of her best qualities. She actually takes the time and effort to record every single pony's likes and dislikes so she can plan the best party possible for them. I don't think it contradicts her having a good memory. I can remember my personal ratings for episodes just fine, but I still like to write them down just in case. Maybe it's the same with Pinkie and the contents of the party cave.

The party cave is only half of Pinkie's strong character display as a character in the episode. Her desire to make others happy and the lengths she can go to do that are also shown in the main story. She's willing to travel across Equestria just so she can get something for the yaks' party. She even stopped a war with nothing but her own talent and kindness! If that's not a big achievement for her as a character, I don't what is.