Talk:Derpy/@comment-77.180.171.226-20120320163632/@comment-89234-20120320185045

That was my first time seeing that video. Major points to the actor and production values, but it does things like conflating "people who thought Derpy was offensive" and "people insulting Derpy, calling her stupid, and literally making her cry by telling her to go away forever" without actually addressing what went wrong.

She sounds more like a compiled version of "fanon" Derpies than the version that actually appeared in the show for a minute. No one would be offended by this Derpy. Become half-convinced that she's "real", loves us all, and desperately needs support against the monsters who banished her for no reason, forcing her to cry in a little spotlight, maybe...

But that isn't what originally went wrong.