Talk:Secrets and Pies/@comment-26423071-20170519110651/@comment-5837525-20170522015927

Certainly. Pinkie's parents aren't abusive. Everything we've seen about them only indicates that they're very conservative.

"no laughs, no smiles, only rocks"


 * Pinkie's been known to exaggerate in her storytelling.

"forcing Pinkie to eating inedible rocks"


 * Proof? She seems to enjoy rock soup just fine in Hearthbreakers.

"refusing to give Pinkie Heart Warming Eve presents"


 * Again, proof? According to Pinkie (also in Hearthbreakers), they hide their presents. They don't withhold them.

"he smiled once,and never again"


 * File:Pinkie Pie's family overjoyed by Pinkie's party S1E23.png
 * File:Granny Smith asks about "apple-farmin' hunks" S5E20.png
 * File:Pie family hopeful again S5E20.png
 * File:Granny trying to talk like Igneous and Cloudy S5E20.png