Talk:Amethyst Star/@comment-70.39.176.20-20130613212901/@comment-25869229-20150406125642

Derpy is too young to have a daughter. The EG Short depicts her as a teen, the same age as Derpy. Unless some sort of Time Machine was invented (Don't slap me with a TARDIS), it's impossible for Derpy to be Amethyst's mother. Logic applied. I rest my case.