FANDOM


Forums: Index > Wiki discussion > Big Macintosh and Granny Smith gallery pages for season 1

A {{delete}} template was added for "Big Macintosh/Gallery/Season 1" and "Granny Smith/Gallery/Season 1" pages with the reason "merged". But I would not be so sure that these page needs to be deleted. I think both characters had enough appearances in S1 which gives the right to separate S1 images in the distinct gallery. This is my opinion. What do you think? Teyandee (Talk) 16:10, April 12, 2012 (UTC)

In my opinion they have appeared enough to warrant the galleries BluesirTheFox FANMADE BluesirTheFox sig image Private Pansy is best pansy 16:16, April 12, 2012 (UTC)
The problem I am facing is that it has little to do about the appearances. It's about the number of pictures in the gallery. Granny Smith and Big Macintosh both had eight appearances for them, but each had only 4 edits (with two of the edits being bots, and one of them was the page being created), no comments, and 19 and 26 pictures, respectively. I didn't want to delete the galleries, in case something like this happens, but I don't think they should have their own season one galleries, at least not right now. FANMADE Pinkie portal front by blackgryph0n-d3f93p8Lord of Shadows Words mean nothing!FANMADE Pinkie portal back by blackgryph0n-d3f93p8 16:49, April 12, 2012 (UTC)
I definitely think they have enough appearances to warrant a separate S1 gallery (being the one who created both of them). As for not having enough pictures, that's an easy fix: we could just ask one of the great picture uploaders (like Ocre, for example) to focus on those pictures for those galleries, as there is an immediate need for pictures to fill them. -- This is Jonny Manz, signing off! 20:00, April 12, 2012 (UTC)
Again, it is not about appearances. Lyra Heartstrings has 19 appearances, and she doesn't have her own season one gallery (I'm not saying we start one, of course. I'm using it as an example). And as for the pictures, you could maybe add 5, 8 pictures tops, to each gallery, and that would still have less than 35 pictures in each gallery. FANMADE Pinkie portal front by blackgryph0n-d3f93p8Lord of Shadows Words mean nothing!FANMADE Pinkie portal back by blackgryph0n-d3f93p8 20:05, April 12, 2012 (UTC)
But then, that begs the question: how many pictures does a Season 1 gallery need to be considered "viable"? I'm fine with getting rid of both of those galleries, as long as we can define that. -- This is Jonny Manz, signing off! 20:22, April 12, 2012 (UTC)
I would assume something like this, if not bigger. Also, I said "At least not right now". When season 3 comes along, we'll have to move many season 2's into their own gallery, and if they have a season one, we'll have to make one for that as well. FANMADE Pinkie portal front by blackgryph0n-d3f93p8Lord of Shadows Words mean nothing!FANMADE Pinkie portal back by blackgryph0n-d3f93p8 20:28, April 12, 2012 (UTC)
Ah, I see; I was wondering: if Season one isn't viable now, and it's over, how will it ever become viable. That makes sense then. I dunno, let's just see how much those galleries can be expanded, and if it's insufficient, we can move them back at that point. -- This is Jonny Manz, signing off! 20:30, April 12, 2012 (UTC)
^That. Also, I would like to state on the record that when the current policy was discussed, I voiced my opinion that the only characters whose images should be shifted to a Season 1 subpage were the main characters plus maybe the CMC. I don't believe the circumstances (= number of season 1 images) have changed. --Tulipclaymore 20:36, April 12, 2012 (UTC)
Well, people are always adding more pictures that aren't there, and I remember the discussion. So far, the only ones that have season one subpages are the main six, the CMC, Derpy, Pinkie Pie being cartoonish, Granny Smith and Big Mac. When season three comes along, however, we'll have to make more galleries, at least for season one (e.g. Lyra Heartstrings/Gallery). FANMADE Pinkie portal front by blackgryph0n-d3f93p8Lord of Shadows Words mean nothing!FANMADE Pinkie portal back by blackgryph0n-d3f93p8 20:41, April 12, 2012 (UTC)
Yeah, I wish we could make Season 1 galleries for both the princesses, but I know (especially in Luna's case) there wouldn't be enough content. Also, I could've sworn more pages had Season 1 galleries; in fact, seeing how Cheerilee and the Mayor had S1 galleries was what inspired me to create those for Big Mac and Granny Smith. -- This is Jonny Manz, signing off! 22:53, April 12, 2012 (UTC)
There were more, but I combined them all. I can't remember which ones other than Cheerilee and Mayor, but I did combine some of them. FANMADE Pinkie portal front by blackgryph0n-d3f93p8Lord of Shadows Words mean nothing!FANMADE Pinkie portal back by blackgryph0n-d3f93p8 22:56, April 12, 2012 (UTC)
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.