View source for Forum:Speculation/Animation/My Little Pony Equestria Girls

{{Forumheader|Speculation|Animation}}

{{Ambox|type=notice|text=This is a [[My Little Pony Friendship is Magic Wiki:Guidelines#Talk pages|talk page]]. Do not edit other contributors' comments.<br />Please sign your posts using four tildes: <nowiki>~~~~</nowiki>}}

* During the song [[Equestria Girls (movie song)|Equestria Girls]] in the cantine there is a part without drums. When they start again, the left tripod is layerd behind a stand, which should be in background there. --[[User:Bahnpirat|Bahnpirat]] ([[User talk:Bahnpirat|talk]])[[File:Microphone_stand_is_on_top_of_cymbal_stand_EG.jpg|thumb|Microphone stand is on top of cymbal stand.]]
* The stadium is missing from the overshot of the Crystal Empire at the start [[User:Glenn31|Glenn31]] ([[User talk:Glenn31|talk]]) 17:42, July 24, 2013 (UTC)[[File:Bird's eye view of Crystal Empire EG.png|thumb|left|Fly-by of Crystal Empire. Stadium is missing.]]
* Sunset Shimmer's cutie mark disappears off her shirt a number of times. [[User:Glenn31|Glenn31]] ([[User talk:Glenn31|talk]]) 17:42, July 24, 2013 (UTC)
*At 14:33, the hallway between Twilight Sparkle and Sunset Shimmer appears empty, however the next clip shows a background girl on Twilight's right side, and then suddenly, another background boy on Twilight's left, which the previous clip showed to be empty. [[User:Cuyut|Cuyut]] ([[User talk:Cuyut|talk]]) 05:07, July 27, 2013 (UTC)
*At 17:24-26, the red bird that flew out of Fluttershy's bag is seen suddenly disappearing out of the air in the next instantaneous clip when she is about to pick up her cat and bunny. [[User:Cuyut|Cuyut]] ([[User talk:Cuyut|talk]]) 05:07, July 27, 2013 (UTC)
*At 32:13, Principal Celestia mentions on the P.A system, "Good morning, students, and happy '''Thursday'''. Just a reminder to pick up your ballots for the Princess of the Fall Formal today. They are due at the time the dance starts '''tomorrow night''', so don't forget to turn them in and make your voice heard."
**This would mean that the Fall Formal was originally scheduled on '''Friday night'''. Throughout all of Thursday, Twilight is able to reunite the mane six, win the votes of the school, while Sunset Shimmer destroys Pinkie Pie's decorations and accuses Twilight for committing it. Flash Sentry defends Twilight's innocence to Vice Principal Luna. Because of the damage Sunset Shimmer caused, Luna states that the dance will have to be postponed '''tomorrow night''', which is basically the same time Celestia mentioned that same morning. Twilight then panics and rejects Flash Sentry's proposal, "If you aren't already going with somebody, wanna go to the Fall Formal with me '''tomorrow night'''?"
**This dialogue mistake from Principal Celestia's announcement during Thursday morning leads to making Twilight's panic and Pinkie Pie's panic at 49:14 (when Pinkie is told by Twilight that the Fall Formal isn't happening tonight) totally irrelevant. If Twilight had listened carefully to what Celestia had said that morning, she would have panicked earlier, and would perhaps have told the truth about herself to the mane six earlier, changing the movie's plot utterly. [[User:Cuyut|Cuyut]] ([[User talk:Cuyut|talk]]) 05:07, July 27, 2013 (UTC)
** The Equestria Girls song and the events after it take place on Friday, the scene at Sugarcube Corner takes place after school on Thursday. Meaning if the dance was postponed another day, it would be held on '''Saturday '''night. [[User:Glenn31|Glenn31]] ([[User talk:Glenn31|talk]]) 14:22, August 5, 2013 (UTC)
*At 57:42, Sunset Shimmer is threatening to destroy the portal by smashing it with a sledgehammer. Solid objects go through the portal such as Twilight Sparkle and her crown. The sledgehammer will not destroy the portal and rather just pass through it, thus making Sunset Shimmer's bluff irrelevant. [[User:Cuyut|Cuyut]] ([[User talk:Cuyut|talk]]) 05:07, July 27, 2013 (UTC)
**This addresses the plot more than the animation, but I'll address it anyway: it's possible Sunset was going to smash not the portal, but the statue ''around'' the portal, causing the portal to collapse. But that's the whole point of the bluff -- whether Sunset was going to smash the portal or the statue, she just needed Twilight to believe she was going to destroy her way home. {{User:ImperfectXIII/Sig}} 08:52, August 22, 2013 (UTC)
*There are inconsistencies on the time difference between travelling from Canterlot High to Equestria through the portal.
**at 10:43, Twilight sees her human hand turn into a hoof when she tests out the portal. This scene creates the assumption that travel between the portal is '''instantaneous'''.
**From 6:16 to 6:26, Sunset Shimmer goes through the mirror about 9 to 10 seconds after the crown goes through. If travelling between the worlds through the portal was '''instant''', then Fluttershy at 16:36 would have had to leave her place in front of the portal within '''10''' seconds after she got the crown in order not to see Sunset Shimmer come out of it.''' '''The time difference of 10 seconds is too short and would have made it unrealistic for Fluttershy not to notice Sunset Shimmer as she arrives at Canterlot High from Equestria.
**at 01:08:40, Spike is seen entering the portal first, just before Twilight when going back to Equestria, yet Twilight is seen first and yet Spike arrives 22 to 23 seconds '''after''' Twilight arrives in Equestria.[[User:Cuyut|Cuyut]] ([[User talk:Cuyut|talk]]) 05:07, July 27, 2013 (UTC)
***Another thing to consider: when Sunset and the crown go through the portal, it's night. When the crown emerges on the other side, it's day. This suggests a distance between Equestria and Canterlot High of at least several hours. Perhaps the gap between the two worlds is more akin to a ''tunnel'' than a ''window'', and it's not the ''travel'' between the worlds that's instantaneous, but the ''transformation'' (hence, Twilight's hand turning into a hoof). {{User:ImperfectXIII/Sig}} 08:52, August 22, 2013 (UTC)
*When Twilight leaves Principal Celestia's office, Celestia is actually in Luna's office, as seen with a crescent moon above the door. [[User:Stboboeminems|Stboboeminems]] ([[User talk:Stboboeminems|talk]]) 14:34, August 20, 2013 (UTC)
**The crescent moon could mean nothing. The interiors of [[:File:Twilight bowing to Principal Celestia EG.png|Celestia]] and [[:File:Twilight in vice-principal Luna's office EG.png|Luna's offices]] look different, as do the designs of [[:File:Twilight and Celestia "my door is always open" EG.png|each of their]] [[:File:Vice-principal Luna EG.png|office doors]]. {{User:ImperfectXIII/Sig}} 08:34, August 22, 2013 (UTC)
*When Sunset complains about Pinkie Pie's decorations, she pops 2 balloons. However, she does not touch the second balloon, meaning it burst naturally. [[User:Stboboeminems|Stboboeminems]] ([[User talk:Stboboeminems|talk]]) 14:34, August 20, 2013
*The lightning bolt on Flash Sentry's shirt [[:File:Twilight, Flash, and Spike in hallway EG.png|gets]] [[:File:Flash smiling at blushing Twilight EG.png|reversed]] [[:File:Flash asks Twilight to the dance EG.png|several]] [[:File:Flash "one no would've been fine" EG.png|times]]. {{User:ImperfectXIII/Sig}} 08:34, August 22, 2013 (UTC)
*During the Equestira Girls song, while one of the Techie's is recording Rainbow Dash, Big Mac, Trixie and DJ-PON3 are behind her. But overhead shots show Big Mac is seated nowhere near there, and is on the other side the cafeteria with AJ (Before she gets up) and the CMC. Later a shot of Big Mac and the CMC's table has them all in diffrent places and a background student seated with them.[[User:Lego3400|Lego3400]] ([[User talk:Lego3400|talk]])
*When Twilight backs to Equestria,Rainbow Dash wing is the same as Twilight
*When Rarity puts a 'disguise' dress on Twilight, she manages to make her backpack remain to hang over it.[[User:Wizeman|Wizeman]] ([[User talk:Wizeman|talk]]) 02:44, August 30, 2013 (UTC)
*How would Rainbow Dash not know what hands are, when Spike has hands? - [[User:Jasonbres|Jasonbres]] ([[User talk:Jasonbres|talk]]) 23:29, September 11, 2013 (UTC)
**Spike has a Claw though. But it raises the bigger question, why don't they know what Hands are, despite the fact that they've used 'Hand' in various expressions before ("On the other hand", "Handful" ETC.)[[User:BabClayton|BabClayton]] ([[User talk:BabClayton|talk]]) 20:55, October 5, 2013 (UTC)
***I think that all those examples with 'Hand' words are creators mistakes:D[[User:Wizeman|Wizeman]] ([[User talk:Wizeman|talk]]) 16:55, December 4, 2013 (UTC)
*Why wouldn't the mane 6 know what dancing is when in various episodes, they can dance?
**I didn't interpret it as them not knowing what dancing was. I interpreted it as just surprise that she was dancing when all she had to do was get her crown. - [[User:Jasonbres|Jasonbres]] ([[User talk:Jasonbres|talk]]) 18:32, April 20, 2014 (UTC)
*<p class="MsoNormal">During the entire soccer scene with Rainbow Dash vs Twilight, Twilight's backpack disappears and then reappears every now and then. [[User:Cuyut|Cuyut]] ([[User talk:Cuyut|talk]]) 00:11, September 15, 2013 (UTC)</p>
*<p class="MsoNormal">When Twilight puts her hand in the portal (When the "hoof error" happens), the portal doesn't shine as it does when Twilight goes through the mirror,the crown goes in and out of the portal,Sunset Shimmer goes through,Twilight goes back to Equestria and comes out of the mirror.</p>
*<p class="MsoNormal">In one of the scenes where the Main 6 are preparing for the Fall Formal, part of Fluttershy's hair curls to the left, on the mirror this is not reversed. <span style="border: 3px solid #2F3173; background-color: #FFF; border-radius: 15px;">{{R|http://i.imgur.com/GjzTyYh.gif|h=30px|link=}} [[User:Seaswirl10|<span title="Seaswirl10" style="color: #964ED9;">'''Seaswirl10'''</span>]] <sup>[[User talk:Seaswirl10|<span title="Talk page" style="color: #964ED9;">'''Talk'''</span>]]</sup>&nbsp;</span> 07:34, November 19, 2013 (UTC)[[File:FANMADE_Fluttershy_Hair_Curl_Mirror_EG.png|thumb]]</p</p>
* When the Crystal Guards are blowing the horns at Twilight's appearance, one of them appears to not blow a horn when Twilight bumps into Flash Sentry. [[User:TheRealStewieG|TheRealStewieG]] ([[User talk:TheRealStewieG|talk]]) 11:16, December 12, 2013 (UTC)
*At 51:19, when Twilight is distributing brooms to her friends during [[Time to Come Together]], Rainbow Dash's right wristband is gone. As soon as she catches her broom, the wristband appears. {{User:ImperfectXIII/Sig}} 23:52, November 10, 2014 (UTC)
*During Time to Come Together, the seein with the male eco kid and the three fashionistas, one of them has a third arm. {{unsigned|Haseo55}}